Oldest Restaurant in Patchogue

In the bustling fishing, oyster farming, shipbuilding, and popular tourist area of Patchogue, Long Island, Pine Grove Inn was built. It was first opened in 1910 to provide food and accommodation to travelers and business people. Until this day, it still provides delicious German food, great cocktails, and alluring waterfront views to its guests.

If you are interested in Pine Grove Inn in Patchogue, then you are on the right page. This article will provide you with a comprehensive overview of the establishment.

A Short Trip Back to Its Beginnings

Pine Grove Inn was initially known for being a 14-room lodging and restaurant among tourists and locals. Legend even says it became a place for smugglers during the Prohibition Era.

In 1946, it was bought by the Buttner family and transformed into a full-time, German-style restaurant. After 11 years, Erna and Rudy Bernreiter became the new owners who served classic German food to Long Islanders.

Finally, it was reopened in 2016 by Michael Goberdhan after being devastated by Superstorm Sandy in 2012. 


They have a total of 6 different menus depending on where you dine or who the diners are. The bar menu has a variety of dishes that you can choose from. If you prefer seafood, they have calamari, baked clams, lobster roll, and so on.

They also serve burgers and sandwiches. There are a variety of salads and appetizers available as well. Everything is also half-price during their Happy Hour. Moreover, children under 12 years old get free juice or soda. When visiting Pine Grove Inn, make sure not to miss their specialty cocktail as well.


For large families or celebrations, their main dining room is the best. It seats up to 80 people who can enjoy an intimate gathering. They also have the old porch room, which is good for 50 people.

This room was originally the porch of the old building, which is why it is called the old porch room. If you want to celebrate something with a great view, then you should reserve the Riverview Room. From this room, you can see the beautiful view of the Swan River. For small gatherings or families, the Swan Room is a good option as it serves up to 16 people.

If you are more of an outdoor person and enjoy fresh air, it is best to dine at the restaurant’s patio. Pine Grove Inn also offers a great place for exchanging vows. Their 8,000 sq. ft lawn is perfect for serene events like weddings.


Pine Grove Inn sometimes facilitates events. In the past, they had the classic drive-in movie night and fright month. What is good about these events is meals are already included upon admission. They also put a lot of effort into arranging the venue to make it engaging for the guests.

Final Words

This is everything you need to know about the oldest standing restaurant in Patchogue. Make sure to visit them and enjoy their luscious meals and exquisite beauty. You might be wondering now how it feels like to be in a historical place, so why not clear your schedule, make a reservation, and revel in the Pine Grove Inn yourself.

Post a Comment